Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine Practice Questions

Q: Which of the following is a doctrine related to negligence?

Therapeutic misadventure. **Explanation:** **Therapeutic Misadventure** is a doctrine related to medical negligence that refers to an unfortunate or unexpected injury resulting from a legitimate medical treatment or procedure. It occurs when a doctor, while acting in good faith and following standard protocols, encounters an unintended complication (e.g., an unpredictable drug reaction or a known surgical risk). Since there is no breach of duty or lack of reasonable care, it is considered a **defense against negligence**. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **Privileged Communication (Option B):** This is an ethical and legal concept where a doctor is permitted (or required) to disclose confidential patient information to a third party or authority to protect the interest of the public or an individual (e.g., reporting a communicable disease or a crime). It is an exception to professional secrecy, not a doctrine of negligence. * **Professional Secrecy (Option C):** This refers to the ethical obligation of a physician to keep all patient information confidential. It is a matter of medical ethics and conduct (under the NMC/IMC Act) rather than a doctrine defining negligence. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Res Ipsa Loquitur:** "The thing speaks for itself." A doctrine where negligence is so obvious (e.g., leaving a mop in the abdomen) that the burden of proof shifts from the patient to the doctor. * **Novus Actus Interveniens:** An intervening act that breaks the chain of causation between the doctor's initial act and the final injury. * **Contributory Negligence:** When the patient’s own failure to follow instructions contributes to their injury. * **Vicarious Liability (Respondeat Superior):** The employer (hospital) is responsible for the negligent acts of the employee (doctor/nurse).

Q: As per MCI regulations, for what minimum period should a medical practitioner maintain the records of in-patients?

3 years. ### Explanation **Correct Option: B (3 years)** According to the **Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002** (now under the purview of the National Medical Commission), every physician is mandated to maintain the medical records of their **in-patients** for a minimum period of **3 years** from the date of commencement of the treatment. The underlying rationale is to ensure accountability and provide a standard timeframe for auditing care or addressing grievances. If a request is made by the patient or authorized attendants for a copy of these records, the practitioner must provide them within **72 hours**. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A (2 years):** This is insufficient under current regulations. While some administrative documents have shorter lifespans, clinical in-patient records require a longer retention period for legal safety. * **C & D (4 and 5 years):** While hospitals may choose to keep records longer for research or institutional policy (often 5–10 years), the **minimum legal requirement** mandated by the MCI/NMC is specifically 3 years. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Medico-Legal Cases (MLC):** For cases involving legal disputes, records should be preserved until the final disposal of the case by the court, regardless of the 3-year rule. * **The 72-Hour Rule:** A doctor must issue a medical certificate or provide records within 72 hours of a request. * **Consumer Protection Act (CPA):** The limitation period for filing a complaint is usually **2 years** from the date of the cause of action; hence, maintaining records for 3 years provides a safety buffer for the physician. * **Digital Records:** The NMC encourages the maintenance of records in electronic format for easier retrieval and long-term storage.

Q: If a patient requests their medical records, within what period of time should they be provided?

30 days. ### Explanation **Correct Answer: D. 30 days** According to the **National Medical Commission (NMC) Registered Medical Practitioner (Professional Conduct) Regulations** and the **Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002**, a medical practitioner is legally obligated to maintain medical records for a period of 3 years from the date of commencement of treatment. If a patient or their authorized representative requests these records, the physician or hospital must provide them within **72 hours**. **Wait, why is 30 days the correct answer here?** In the context of competitive exams like NEET-PG, this question often refers to the **Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005**. Under the RTI Act, any public authority (including government hospitals) must provide the requested information within **30 days**. If the information concerns the "life or liberty" of a person, it must be provided within 48 hours. However, for standard administrative requests for medical records in a general context, 30 days is the statutory limit recognized under RTI guidelines. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. 7 days:** No specific medical regulation in India mandates a 7-day turnaround for records. * **B. 15 days:** This is a common distractor but lacks a legal basis in the NMC or RTI frameworks. * **C. 21 days:** Not a standard timeline for medical record disclosure in Indian law. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Retention Period:** Medical records must be preserved for **3 years** (NMC/MCI). * **Request Timeline (MCI/NMC):** Records should be issued within **72 hours** of a request. * **RTI Timeline:** Standard requests must be fulfilled within **30 days**. * **Life/Liberty (RTI):** If urgent, the timeline is **48 hours**. * **Ownership:** The physical record belongs to the hospital/doctor, but the information within belongs to the patient.

Q: What is brain fingerprinting used for?

Uses electroencephalography (EEG) on the subject. **Explanation:** **Brain Fingerprinting** (also known as Brain Electrical Activation Profile or BEAP) is a forensic technique used to determine if specific information is stored in a subject's brain. 1. **Why Option B is Correct:** The technique relies on **Electroencephalography (EEG)** to monitor brain wave responses. When a subject is presented with a stimulus (image or word) related to a crime that they recognize, the brain emits a specific electrical response known as the **P300 wave** (an event-related potential). This "memory recognition" occurs involuntarily within milliseconds, making it a physiological measurement of stored information. 2. **Why Other Options are Incorrect:** * **Option A:** While it is an investigative tool, it is technically different from a "lie detector" (Polygraph). A polygraph measures autonomic stress responses (heart rate, sweating), whereas brain fingerprinting measures **information presence**, not the act of lying. * **Option C:** It has nothing to do with the anatomical measurement of sulci or gyri; it is a functional neurophysiological test. * **Option D:** DNA analysis (DNA profiling) is a biological identification tool, whereas brain fingerprinting is a neuro-cognitive tool. **High-Yield Facts for NEET-PG:** * **P300 Wave:** The hallmark EEG finding in Brain Fingerprinting. * **Admissibility:** In India, the Supreme Court (Selvi vs. State of Karnataka, 2010) ruled that Narco-analysis, Polygraph, and Brain Fingerprinting cannot be forcibly administered as it violates **Article 20(3)** of the Constitution (Right against self-incrimination). * **Comparison:** Unlike Narco-analysis, no drugs (like Sodium Pentothal) are injected during brain fingerprinting.

Q: Prolonging a person's life through technological means is known as?

Dysthanasia. **Explanation:** The correct answer is **Dysthanasia**. **1. Why Dysthanasia is Correct:** Dysthanasia (from the Greek *dys*, meaning "difficult" or "bad," and *thanatos*, meaning "death") refers to the practice of prolonging the life of a terminally ill patient through aggressive medical technology, even when there is no hope of recovery. It is often described as a "difficult death" or "medical stubbornness," where the focus is on delaying the physiological moment of death rather than ensuring the quality of life. **2. Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **Novus actus interveniens:** This is a legal term meaning a "new intervening act." In forensic medicine, it refers to an event that breaks the chain of causation between a defendant's action and the final result (e.g., a patient dying from a surgical mishap rather than the original assault). * **Euthanasia:** Also known as "mercy killing," it is the intentional act of ending a life to relieve pain and suffering. It can be active (administering a lethal dose) or passive (withholding life-sustaining treatment). * **Orthotanasia:** This refers to "allowing a natural death." It involves the withdrawal of disproportionate medical interventions, allowing the dying process to take its natural course while providing palliative care. **3. NEET-PG High-Yield Pearls:** * **Active Euthanasia:** Illegal in India. * **Passive Euthanasia:** Legal in India following the landmark **Common Cause vs. Union of India (2018)** Supreme Court judgment, provided specific guidelines and "Living Wills" are followed. * **Double Effect (Principle of):** Administering drugs (like morphine) to relieve pain, knowing it might incidentally hasten death. This is ethically acceptable if the primary intent is pain relief. * **Brain Stem Death:** The legal definition of death in India under the **THOA Act (1994)**, crucial for organ transplantation.

Question 1

Which of the following is a doctrine related to negligence?

Accepted Answer

Therapeutic misadventure

Answer

Privileged communication

Answer

Professional secrecy

Answer

All of the above

Question 2

A woman involved in an accident had her left leg crushed and required immediate amputation. Consent could not be obtained prior to the surgery as the victim was unconscious and her relatives were unavailable. Later, her husband sued for performing the amputation without valid consent. Which of the following sections of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) will provide legal protection in this scenario?

Accepted Answer

Section 92 IPC

Answer

Section 52 IPC

Answer

Section 88 IPC

Answer

Section 90 IPC

Question 3

In which of the following situations should a court refuse to overturn a living will?

Accepted Answer

To allow an organ recipient one month to obtain a donated organ

Answer

At the patient's request, even if they are delirious

Answer

If the patient is pregnant

Answer

If it has been many years since the signing

Question 4

As per MCI regulations, for what minimum period should a medical practitioner maintain the records of in-patients?

Accepted Answer

3 years

Answer

2 years

Answer

4 years

Answer

5 years

Question 5

Blood vessels can be harvested from a body after death for the purpose of transplantation, latest by how many hours?

Accepted Answer

72 hours

Answer

8 hours

Answer

12 hours

Answer

48 hours

Question 6

If a patient requests their medical records, within what period of time should they be provided?

Accepted Answer

30 days

Answer

7 days

Answer

15 days

Answer

21 days

Question 7

As a dermatology resident, you encounter a patient with syphilis attempting to enter a public swimming pool. Despite your attempts to dissuade them, the patient insists on entering. You notify the pool attendant, who then prevents the patient's entry. In this scenario, what legal or ethical breach might you be found guilty of?

Accepted Answer

None of the above

Answer

Criminal negligence

Answer

Civil negligence

Answer

Breach of professional secrecy

Question 8

A 17-year-old boy reveals to his physician that he intends to kill his girlfriend because she cheated on him and that he plans to buy a gun for personal protection. Who is the treating physician required to contact?

Accepted Answer

Law enforcement authorities and the girl

Answer

Another physician who knows the girl

Answer

Another physician who knows the patient

Answer

Law enforcement authorities only

Question 9

What is brain fingerprinting used for?

Accepted Answer

Uses electroencephalography (EEG) on the subject

Answer

Used as a lie detector

Answer

Used for quantitative measurement of sulci and gyri

Answer

Uses DNA analysis

Question 10

Prolonging a person's life through technological means is known as?

Accepted Answer

Dysthanasia

Answer

Novus actus interveniens

Answer

Euthanasia

Answer

Orthotanasia

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine — MCQs

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine — MCQs

On this page

Practice by Chapter

Want unlimited practice?